So he knew there was an incident and knew the police were involved and knew there was no arrest. What matters is when he became aware of the 2015 incident what did he do?
If OSU believes he knew about previous events and they were not reported he would likely get fired. So lets assume he was not aware of all the stuff Courtney Smith alleges.
: You said "the issue seems to me to be for Urban "you were aware of a potential domestic violence situation with a member of your staff and what did you do about it", then said "Urban doesn't know what was really occuring at the Smith household." If he didn't know what was occurring at the household, how could he have been aware of potential domestic violence?